A detailed side-by-side of fees, giving channels, church-management tools, and payout speed, the numbers that actually matter to a church.
| #1 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Fees & cost | ||
| Card processing fee | 2.9% + 30¢Amex 3.5% | 2.9% + 30¢Amex 3.5% |
| ACH / bank transfer fee | 1% + 30¢ | ✗no ACH (card only) |
| Monthly / platform fee | $0 coreadd-ons $19–$119/mo | None |
| Donors can cover fees | ✓ | ✓ |
| Giving experience | ||
| Recurring / scheduled giving | ✓ | ✓ |
| Text-to-give | ✓$19/mo add-on | ✗ |
| Giving channels | Online · in-app · kiosk · QR · text | Online · in-app · QR |
| Church-discovery map | ✗ | ✓ |
| Church tools | ||
| Church management (ChMS) | ✓native $72/mo + integrations | ✗minimal; pairs with a ChMS |
| Donor tax statements | ✓ | ✓cross-org |
| Access & value | ||
| Payout speed | ~1–3 business daysto confirm | Next business day |
| Setup / contract | $0 setup · no contract | $0 setup · no contract |
| Non-church nonprofits | ✓ | ✓ |
| Platforms | iOS · Android · Web | iOS · Android · Web |
| Design & experience | ||
| Design & UX rating | 7.5 / 10 | 8.5 / 10 |
Fast-track a full column for your app in this side-by-side, in front of high-intent readers choosing between the best giving apps. Paying gets you included, never ranked: your column is scored by the same public rubric as every app here. Have a feature nobody else has? Add your own comparison row for $10, a row only you can win.
For a church buyer, fees and cost carry the most weight, followed by giving channels and church-management depth; donor experience, payout speed, design, and simplicity round it out.
By our rubric, Tithe.ly ranks first with a score of 86/100, it supports every giving channel (online, in-app, kiosk, QR, and text), adds a cheaper 1% + 30¢ ACH option, and includes a native church-management system, all on a free giving core. Givelify (80) is the strongest pick for a small church that wants zero monthly fees, the fastest setup, and next-business-day deposits.
Both charge the same 2.9% + 30¢ on card gifts (3.5% on Amex). Tithe.ly is cheaper on recurring giving because it offers ACH bank transfers at 1% + 30¢, while Givelify is card-only with no ACH. Givelify has no monthly platform fee at all; Tithe.ly’s giving core is $0 but its add-ons run $19–$119/mo and its native ChMS is $72/mo.
We apply one public rubric to the feature data: fees & cost (25%), church management (16%), giving channels (14%), donor experience (13%), design & UX (12%), value / simplicity (12%), and payout speed (8%). No app can pay to change its rank.
No. The ranking is earned from the rubric and can never be bought. An app can pay to be included as a clearly-labeled comparison entry, but that inclusion is additive and never reorders or rescores the earned apps.